Peter Pays Paul

Where is the Market?

One of the most difficult tasks for commercial real estate professionals is determining where the market is today. Too few transactions, too much distress, unrealistic sellers, and opportunistic buyers make the demand for property and the proper pricing of property an exercise in futility.

Determining a rate of return commensurate with risk is difficult in these uncertain times.

Three news stories illustrate this point.

Retail Center in Vallejo, CA

GlobeSt.com is reporting that the First Grocery-Anchored Sale Closes, More to Come. The article details the sale of a 66,000 square feet Safeway anchored center in Vallejo, CA.

According to the article the property sold based on a 7.71% cap rate on current NOI. As well, the seller had an assumable loan at below market rates providing an attractive cash-on-cash return for the buyer.

The cash yield seems to be the bigger selling point. Dan Wald of Terranomics said that investors are requiring a 10% cash yield on investments.

While this property gives us an idea of the value, it is not a firm indicator. This center is well located at the entrance to a housing development. A superior location would induce a buyer to pay a higher price for the lower risk.

AIG Headquarters in Manhattan

CPN is reporting that the AIG Headquarters Sale Makes Splash in Quiet Manhattan Investment Market. (HT: David Stejkowski)

Youngwoo & Associates (YWA), a New York-based investment and development firm, together with Kumho Investment Bank (Kumho), entered into an agreement to acquire the AIG building, 70 Pine Street (pictured), and an adjacent office building, 72 Wall Street. The two buildings will total 1.4 million rentable square feet in the heart of Manhattan’s Financial District.

The rumored salesprice is around $100 million. This would value the property at around $100 per square foot.

While this may be the biggest acquisition in New York, the entire property is going to be vacated once AIG is wound down. This again doesn’t establish a firm enough foundation for other investors.

Office Building in Orange County, CA

The WSJ has an article explaing why Maguire Sells Office Site at 40% Off.

Maguire Properties Inc., a struggling Los Angeles-based real-estate investment trust, sold a newly developed office building in Irvine, Calif., for about $160 million, a price representing an estimated 40% discount to its construction cost.

The price of 3161 Michelson Drive, during a lean year for commercial real-estate sales, is the latest sign of the severe drop in values in the commercial real-estate market, which is threatening to become a major anchor around the economy just as it is struggling to come back to life.

This property like the AIG bulding suffers from vacancy issues. As well the seller was under pressure to reduce their debt load and needed to sell the asset.

The Bottom Line

Each of these sales while indicative of the current market demand and supply are not conclusive enough to determine a market pricing strategy.

Until owners begin to sell non-distressed assets, market pricing will be a moving target.

Share on Twitter

Related Posts

• Another Unscrupulous Hard Money Lender
• How to Find Distressed Properties #2
• Determining Market CAP Rates
• Thawing Out Commercial Real Estate Capital
• Doctor’s Are Still Buying Office Space